Sister Lúcia

From Justapedia, unleashing the power of collective wisdom
(Redirected from Lucia Santos)
Jump to navigation Jump to search


Sister Lúcia of Fátima

Duas Entrevistas com a Irmã Lúcia (Português) by Carlos Evaristo (cropped).jpg
Sister Lúcia at the Discalced Carmelite Monastery of Coimbra, circa 1998
Virgin
BornLúcia de Jesus Rosa dos Santos
(1907-03-28)28 March 1907
Aljustrel, Fátima
Kingdom of Portugal
Died13 February 2005(2005-02-13) (aged 97)
Coimbra, Portugal

Lúcia de Jesus Rosa dos Santos, OCD, (28 March 1907 – 13 February 2005) also known as Lúcia of Fátima and by her religious name Maria Lúcia of Jesus and of the Immaculate Heart,[1] was a Portuguese Catholic Discalced Carmelite nun, one of the three children, along with her cousins Francisco and Jacinta Marto, who claimed to have witnessed Marian apparitions in Fátima in 1917.

Early life

Lúcia was the youngest child of António dos Santos and Maria Rosa Ferreira (1869–1942),[2] both from Aljustrel, who married on 19 November 1890.[1] She had six brothers and sisters: Maria dos Anjos (1891–1986), Teresa de Jesus Rosa dos Santos, Manuel Rosa dos Santos (1895-1977), Glória de Jesus Rosa dos Santos (1898–1971), Carolina de Jesus Rosa dos Santos (1902–1992), and Maria Rosa (died at birth).[citation needed] Although peasants, the Santos family was by no means poor, owning land "in the direction of Montelo, Ortiga, Fátima, Valinhos, Cabeço, Charneca, and Cova da Iria."[3]: 9 

The birthplace of Lúcia in Aljustrel, Fátima.
Photograph of Lúcia with her family in 1919. In the foreground: Lúcia with her mother Maria Rosa (1869-1942); in the background, Lúcia's siblings. From left to right: Manuel dos Santos (1895-1977), Maria dos Anjos (1891-1986) with her daughter Glória (1917-1934); Carolina (1902-1992) and Glória de Jesus (1898-1971).

Even though Lúcia's birthday is registered as 22 March 1907, her actual date of birth is 28 March. In those days, it was required that parents bring their children for baptism on the eighth day after birth or face a fine, and, because 30 March was a more convenient day, the 22nd was chosen as her birthday. Lúcia later recalled that, at the time, no one attached much importance to one's birthday.[3]: 13–14 

Lúcia's father António, by her report, was a hardworking and generous man. Lúcia remembered him telling fairy tales and singing folk songs, but he was also the one who first taught her to make the Sign of the Cross. Contrary to popular hagiographical accounts of the apparitions, he believed the children and there is some evidence that he conspired to make sure Lúcia got to the Cova for the visitations after her mother had forbidden it. Lúcia said that her father was not a particularly heavy drinker, but liked to socialize in the tavern. Because he did not like Fr. Ferreira, he went to church in a nearby town.[note 1]

Maria Rosa was literate, although she never taught her children to read. She had a taste for religious literature and storytelling. She gave catechism lessons[note 2] to her children and the neighbor's children, if they were there, at siesta time during the summer and especially around Lent. During the winter, catechism lessons took place after supper and around the fire.[4]: 38, 69  According to her mother, Lúcia repeated everything that she heard "like a parrot."[4]: 67 

Fr. De Marchi described her features in the following manner: "She was not a pretty child. The only attractions of her face—which was not on the whole repellent—were her two great black eyes which gazed out from under thick eyebrows. Her hair, thick and dark, was parted in the center over her shoulders. Her nose was rather flat, her lips thick and her mouth large."[5]

Lúcia was a fabulous storyteller with a "gift for narration."[6]: 11  She had a talent for composing original songs, with catchy folk-style tunes and sacred and secular lyrics. Among the songs she invented as a small child are "In Heaven, I'll Be With My Mother", "I Love God in Heaven", and "Lady of Carmel". She set to music the words of the brief prayer she said had been taught to her and her cousins by the Angel of Portugal: "O God, I believe, I adore, I hope, and I love Thee. I ask forgiveness for those who do not believe, nor hope, nor love Thee."[This quote needs a citation] She also wrote a poem about Jacinta which appears in her memoirs.

Lúcia's First Communion occurred at six years of age despite ten being the usual minimum. Initially, the parish priest refused because of her young age. However, Father Cruz, a Jesuit missionary visiting from Lisbon, interviewed Lúcia after finding her in tears that day and concluded that "she understands what she's doing better than many of the others." Because of this intervention, the parish priest admitted Lúcia to Holy Communion.[7][better source needed] After her First Confession she prayed before the altar of Our Lady of the Rosary and saw the statue smile at her. Upon receiving the Eucharist, Lúcia felt "bathed in such a supernatural atmosphere that the presence of our dear Lord became as clearly perceptible to me as if I had seen and heard Him with my bodily senses."[citation needed] Lúcia's First Communion left a deep impact on her. "I lost the taste and attraction for the things of the world, and only felt at home in some solitary place where, all alone, I could recall the delights of my First Communion."[4]: 72–73 

By eight years of age, she was tending the family's sheep, accompanied by other boys and girls of the village.[1]

Apparitions of Our Lady of Fátima

Lúcia dos Santos (left) with fellow visionaries of Our Lady, Francisco and Jacinta Marto

Between May and October 1917, Lúcia and her cousins Jacinta and Francisco Marto reported visions of a luminous lady, who they believed to be the Virgin Mary, in the Cova da Iria fields outside the hamlet of Aljustrel, near Fátima, Portugal.[8] The children said the visitations took place on the 13th day of each month at approximately noon, for six straight months. The only exception was August, when the children were detained by the local administrator. That month they did not report a vision of the Lady until after they were released from jail, two days later.

According to Lúcia's accounts, the lady told the children to do penance and to make sacrifices to save sinners. Lúcia said that the lady stressed the importance of saying the Rosary every day, to bring peace to the world.[9] Many young Portuguese men, including relatives of the visionaries, were then fighting in World War I.[10][better source needed] Lúcia heard Mary ask her to learn to read and write because Jesus wanted to employ her to convey messages to the world about Mary, particularly the Immaculate Heart of Mary.

Lúcia's mother did not take kindly to the news that her youngest daughter was having visitations, believing that Lúcia was simply making up lies for attention. Heretofore the favorite, Lúcia, suffered beatings and ridicule from her mother. She was especially incredulous of the idea that Lúcia had been asked to learn to read and write.[6]: 72 

Three Secrets of Fatima

Lúcia (standing) with her cousin, Jacinta Marto, 1917

On 13 July 1917, around noon, the lady is said to have entrusted the children with three secrets. Two of the secrets were revealed in 1941 in a document written by Lúcia, at the request of the Bishop of Leiria, José Alves Correia da Silva, partly to assist with the publication of a new edition of a book on Jacinta.[11]: 199 

When asked by José Alves Correia da Silva, Bishop of Leiria, in 1943 to reveal the third secret, Lúcia struggled for a short period, being "not yet convinced that God had clearly authorized her to act".[11]: 203  She was under strict obedience in accordance with her Carmelite life, and conflicted as to whether she should obey her superiors, or the personal orders she believed were from Mary. However, in October 1943 she fell ill with influenza and pleurisy, the same illness which had killed her cousins, and for a time believed she was about to die. Bishop Da Silva then ordered her to put the third secret in writing.[11]: 204  Lúcia then wrote down the secret and sealed it in an envelope not to be opened until 1960. [12] She designated 1960 because she thought that "by then it will appear clearer."[11]: 208–09  The text of the third secret was officially released by Pope John Paul II in 2000.

The Vatican described the secret as a vision of the 1981 assassination attempt on Pope John Paul II.[13]

Miracle of the Sun

The visions increasingly received wide publicity, and an estimated 70,000 witnesses were reportedly present for the sixth and final apparition.[9] Lúcia had promised for several months that the lady would perform a miracle on that day "so that all may believe." Witnesses present in the Cova da Iria that day, as well as some up to 25 miles (40 km) away,[14]: 192  reported that the Sun appeared to change colors and rotate, like a fire wheel, casting off multicolored light across the landscape. The Sun appeared to plunge towards the Earth, frightening many into believing that it was the end of the world.[14]: 183–91 [15]: 53–62, 87  Others suggested they had merely witnessed an eclipse.[9] The popular expression, according to the O Século reporter Avelino de Almeida, was that the Sun "danced."[15]: 2  The event became known as the Miracle of the Sun. The episode was widely reported by the Portuguese secular media. Some coverage appeared in a small article in the New York Times on 17 October 1917.[16] Lúcia reported that day that the Lady identified herself as "Our Lady of the Rosary." She thereafter also became known as Our Lady of Fátima.

On behalf of the Catholic Church, Bishop Da Silva approved the visions as "worthy of belief" on 13 October 1930.[17]

Life in the convent

Sister Lúcia in the Chapel of the Apparitions next to the column which marking the place where the apparitions of Our Lady are said to have taken place. The picture was taken during Lucia's visit to Cova da Iria on May 22, 1946

Lúcia moved to Porto in 1921, and at 14 was admitted as a boarder in the school of the Sisters of St. Dorothy in Vilar, on the city's outskirts. On 24 October 1925, she entered the Institute of the Sisters of St. Dorothy as a postulant in the convent in Pontevedra, Spain, just across the northern Portuguese border.[18] According to Sister Lúcia, on 10 December 1925, she experienced a vision of the Holy Virgin and the Christ Child. The Virgin Mary is said to have requested the practice of the Five First Saturdays devotion. If one fulfilled the conditions on the First Saturday of five consecutive months, the Virgin Mary promised special graces at the hour of death.[19]

On 20 July 1926, Lucia moved to Tuy, where she began her novitiate; she received her habit on 2 October of the same year. Lúcia professed her first vows on 3 October 1928. Sister Lucia reported that on 13 June 1929, she had a vision during which the Blessed Virgin told her: "The moment has come in which God asks the Holy Father, in union with all the bishops of the world, to make the consecration of Russia to my Immaculate Heart, promising to save it by this means."[20] She made her perpetual vows on 3 October 1934,[18] receiving the name "Sister Maria das Dores" (Mary of the Sorrows).

On 25 January 1938, a massive aurora borealis, described variously as "a curtain of fire" and a "huge blood-red beam of light", appeared in the skies over Europe and was visible as far away as Gibraltar and even parts of the United States.[21] Lúcia believed this event was the "night illuminated by a strange light in the sky"[This quote needs a citation] which she had heard Mary speak about as part of the Second Secret, predicting the events which would lead to the Second World War and requesting Acts of Reparation including the First Saturday Devotions along with the Consecration of Russia.

She returned to Portugal in 1946 (where she visited Fátima incognito), and in March 1948, after receiving special papal permission to be relieved of her perpetual vows, entered the Carmelite convent of Santa Teresa in Coimbra, where she resided until her death.[8] She made her profession as a Discalced Carmelite on 31 May 1949, taking the religious name Sister Maria Lúcia of Jesus and the Immaculate Heart.

Because of the Constitutions of the community, Lúcia was expected to "converse as little as possible with persons from without, even with their nearest relatives, unless their conversation be spiritual, and even then it should be very seldom and as brief as possible"[note 3] and "have nothing to do with worldly affairs, nor speak of them".[note 4] This has led some people to believe in a conspiracy to cover up the Fátima message and silence Lúcia.[22]

Pope Paul VI with Sister Lúcia in 1967
Meeting of Sister Lúcia with Pope John Paul II in the Sanctuary of Fátima on 13 May 2000

She came back to Fátima on the occasion of four papal pilgrimages – all on 13 May – firstly by Paul VI in 1967, and John Paul II in 1982 (in thanksgiving for surviving an assassination attempt the previous year), 1991, and 2000 when her cousins Jacinta and Francisco were beatified. On 16 May 2000, she unexpectedly returned to Fátima to visit the parish church.[citation needed]

Writings

Sister Lúcia wrote six memoirs during her lifetime. The first four were written between 1935 and 1941, and the English translation is published under the name Fatima in Lucia's Own Words. The fifth and six memoirs, written in 1989 and 1993, are published in English under the name Fatima in Lucia's Own Words II. These latter books were written in her own handwriting.[citation needed]

An additional book was published in 2001, variously known as Calls from the Message of Fatima and Appeals from the Message of Fatima, as announced by the Vatican on 5 December 2001.[23]

Sister Lúcia also wrote numerous letters to clergy and devout laypeople who were curious about the Third Secret of Fátima and about Lúcia's interpretation of what she had heard Virgin Mary request.[note 5] Two letters she supposedly wrote concerned the Consecration of Russia, in which she said Our Lady's request had been fulfilled.[24] Any and all material written by Sister Lúcia is now held for study by the Congregation for the Causes of Saints.[25]

Death

Sister Lúcia had been blind and deaf and ailing for some years prior to her death. She died at the Carmelite convent of Santa Teresa in Coimbra, where she had lived since 1948.[8]

In Portugal, 15 February 2005 was declared a day of national mourning; even campaigning for the national parliamentary election scheduled for Sunday, 20 February, was interrupted. Sister Lúcia was a registered voter (as are all Portuguese citizens), and her polling place visits were covered by the Portuguese press.[citation needed]

Imposter controversy

Experts from different fields have drawn conclusions that the Sister Lúcia who appeared post 1967 and that prior to 1960 are two different people.

Forensic artists

Lois Gibson analysed various samples of Sister Lúcia and gave the following assessment:

"As explained in Our Lady of Fátima Nun Comparisons One, Two, and Three, it appears the original nun was substituted years after her first appearance. Above I have the substitute nun shown A, at her youngest appearance. B and C are her as she appeared older and oldest in that order. It is my expert opinion that the substitute nun is one and the same individual. Said differently, it appears the first nun was not the same woman who appeared above in later years, and was named as that same nun, meaning there was a substitution. However, there was never more than one nun substituted for the original nun attached to the miracle of Our Lady of Fátima."[26]

Historical contradictions

It is alleged[according to whom?] that the tone and content of the messaging of Sister Lúcia prior to and inclusive of 1957 is different than that of the post 1967 Lúcia.[27]

Examples

Alleged historical contradictions
Pre-1957 Post-1967
As a dorothean she was forbidden to talk about Fátima by Mother Superior (she was given permission only once) Allowed to talk about Fátima by Mother Superior multiple times
Hidden from the public as 'Mary of Sorrows' Actively in the public with Pope Paul VI and successors[28]
Appearance is sad and pale[29] Appearance is joyful and happy
During the apparition of the Blessed Trinity and the Virgin Mary, Our Lady requests the consecration of Russia to her immaculate heart Lúcia claiming that the consecration had already occurred
Punishment for the world is imminent due to sins[30] Claiming that she is unaware of anything associated with punishment[31]

Medical experts

A few medical experts have indicated that Lúcia may have been substituted:

Dr Mascro's (Oral Surgeon) opinion:

"Lúcia I’s mouth/teeth tend to extend anteriorly (forward). In other words, her mouth area sticks out relative to her other facial structures. This is an underlying feature of Lúcia I’s skeletal structure. This skeletal structure would not significantly change if all of her teeth were extracted and dentures worn. In contrast, Lúcia II’s profile presents a nearly opposite condition: a prognathic profile with a concave appearance.
"Lúcia II presents maxilla (upper jaw) retrusion and mandibular protrusion. This protrusion is observable as Lúcia II’s mandible/chin is nearly parallel to the tip of her nose, a spot anterior to her nostrile. Yet, Lúcia I’s chin is recessed relative to the tip of her nose. The most anterior part of Lúcia I’s chin is vertically aligned to a spot posterior to her nostril."[32]

Dr Garcia (board certified plastic surgeon) concludes:

"As a board-certified Plastic Surgeon, I am of the opinion that Subject B and Subject C share some similarities, but I am very confident they are not the same individual. The strongest evidence for this conclusion is the discrepancy between the chins. Subject C and Subject D have far more prominent, protrusive chins when compared to the profile view of Subject B. This difference cannot be explained by the aging process. Nor could dental work account for the observed discrepancy. In addition, Subject B’s eyelids provide additional evidence that Subject B is a different individual than the individual pictured in Subject C and Subject D"[33]

Canonization process

On 13 February 2008 (the third anniversary of her death), Pope Benedict XVI announced that in the case of Sister Lúcia he would waive the five-year waiting period established by ecclesiastical law before opening a cause for beatification.[34] On 13 February 2017, Sister Lúcia was accorded the title Servant of God, as the first major step toward her canonization.[35]

In popular culture

Lúcia is played by Susan Whitney in the 1952 film The Miracle of Our Lady of Fatima.

Felipa Fernandes played her in The 13th Day, a straight-to-video feature film produced by Natasha Howes and directed by Dominic and Ian Higgins.

In the 2020 film Fatima, Lúcia is played by Stephanie Gil as the young seer and by Sônia Braga as the adult nun.

See also

Notes

  1. ^ "As for the drinking, again thanks be to God, it was not as they say, nor as Fr. De Marchi wrote in the first edition of his book, A Lady More Brilliant than the Sun. If my father did sometimes drink a little more than those who drank nothing, he never carried it to the point of creating disorder at home, nor of ill treating his wife and children..." —Lucia's Fifth Memoir Archived 30 December 2015 at the Wayback Machine, entire text online, page found 6 June 2011.
  2. ^ "Mother was never satisfied with our just being able to repeat the words of our catechism. She tried hard to explain everything so we would really understand the meaning of the words. She used to say that just repeating catechism without understanding was worse than useless." —Maria dos Anjos Santos, in de Marchi's True Story of Fatima Maria dos Anjos was made an official catechist at the age of nine, a testament to her mother's diligence.
  3. ^ Rule and Constitutions of the Discalced Nuns of the Blessed Virgin Mary of Mount Carmel (1990), paragraph 27. While this document was binding for Sr. Lúcia only at the end of her life, it is based on the Constitutions of St. Teresa of Jesus, which were written in the 16th century.
  4. ^ Rule and Constitutions of the Discalced Nuns of the Blessed Virgin Mary of Mount Carmel (1990), paragraph 23. See also, paragraphs 212–214 on the strict nature of the cloister. It is quite unusual that, as a nun of her Order, Sr. Lúcia was able to produce any public writings at all.
  5. ^ Some examples of these letters are reprinted in The Whole Truth About Fatima Archived 23 December 2009 at the Wayback Machine, particularly in Volume 4, Fatima and John Paul I Archived 27 June 2010 at the Wayback Machine.

References

  1. ^ a b c "Servant of God Lucia Santos". EWTN. Irondale, Alabama: Eternal Word Television Network, Inc. Retrieved 12 July 2016.
  2. ^ Duarte, Marco Daniel, ed. (2012). Francisco e Jacinta Marto: candeias que Deus acendeu [Francisco and Jacinta Marto: Candles that God Lit] (in Portuguese). Santuário de Fátima. ISBN 978-972-8213-83-1.
  3. ^ a b Dos Santos, Lúcia (1999). Fátima in Lúcia's Own Words. Vol. II.
  4. ^ a b c Dos Santos, Lúcia (2003). Fátima in Lúcia's Own Words. Vol. I.
  5. ^ De Marchi, John. Fátima The Full Story, p. 31.
  6. ^ a b Walsh, William Thomas. Our Lady of Fátima
  7. ^ Fátima in Lúcia's Own Words (1995) pp. 54–55
  8. ^ a b c Davison, Phil (16 February 2005). "Obituary: Sister Lucia dos Santos". The Guardian. ISSN 0261-3077. Retrieved 14 October 2020.
  9. ^ a b c "Sister Lucia De Jesus Dos Santos". The Telegraph. Retrieved 14 October 2020.
  10. ^ De Marchi
  11. ^ a b c d Zimdars-Swartz, Sandra L., Encountering Mary (1991)
  12. ^ "News Features". www.catholicculture.org. Retrieved 14 October 2020.
  13. ^ "Vatican Discloses 'Third Secret' of Fatima". archive.nytimes.com. Retrieved 14 October 2020.
  14. ^ a b John De Marchi, (1956) The True Story of Fátima
  15. ^ a b Stanley Jaki (1999), God and the Sun at Fátima
  16. ^ The New York Times, 17 October 1917
  17. ^ Joseph Pelletier. (1983). The Sun Danced at Fátima. Doubleday, New York. p. 147–151.
  18. ^ a b "Lucia dos Santos and Fatima", Marian Library, University of Dayton
  19. ^ Fastiggi, Robert. "The meaning of Fatima", OSV Newsweekly, 1 January 2017
  20. ^ "The meaning of Fatima: 100 years later", OSV News, 1 January 2017
  21. ^ Storms, Solar (18 April 2017). "January 25, 1938 The Fatima Storm". www.solarstorms.org. Retrieved 14 October 2020.
  22. ^ Bertone, Tarcisio (2008). The Last Secret of Fatima. Doubleday Religion. pp. 65–66. ISBN 978-0-385-52582-4.
  23. ^ ZENIT – Sister Lucia Writes Book on Fatima Revelations
  24. ^ Letters of Sister Lúcia dos Santos, OCD on the Consecration[dead link]
  25. ^ Sister Lúcia of Fatima Takes Step Toward Beatification. National Catholic Register, 14 February 2017.
  26. ^ Gibson, Lois (2 March 2020). "Second Forensic Report" (PDF). Sister Lucy Truth. Retrieved 20 September 2022.
  27. ^ ""Fatima Fraud - Our Case for an Imposter Lucy" - Full Film". YouTube.
  28. ^ "Portugal: Pope John Paul Ii Visit". YouTube.
  29. ^ "Fr. Fuentes interview with Sr. Lucia". 2 July 2019.
  30. ^ "Fr. Fuentes interview with Sr. Lucia". 2 July 2019.
  31. ^ ""Fatima Fraud - Our Case for an Imposter Lucy" - Full Film". YouTube.
  32. ^ https://sisterlucytruth.org/wp-content/uploads/2020/07/Oral-Surgeon-Mascaro-Report.pdf[bare URL PDF]
  33. ^ https://sisterlucytruth.org/wp-content/uploads/2019/01/Dr-Julio-Garcia-Opinion.pdf[bare URL PDF]
  34. ^ "Sister Lucia's Beatification Process to Begin". Vatican City: Zenit. 13 February 2008. Archived from the original on 27 September 2012.
  35. ^ "Sister Lucia of Fatima Takes Step Toward Beatification". NCR. Retrieved 14 October 2020.

External links